RSS

Tag Archives: Grassy Knoll eyewitnesses

JFK Dealey Plaza Witnesses: A Survey Comparison

24 Feb online usa casinos accepting echeck how to play roulette in a casino triple diamond slot machine payout

JFK Dealey Plaza Witnesses: A Survey Comparison

Richard Charnin
Feb. 26, 2014
Updated: Feb. 28, 2014

Click Reclaiming Science:The JFK Conspiracy to look inside the book.

JFK Blog Posts
JFK Calc Spreadsheet Database
Tables and Graphs

Slot machine win sound effect juegos casino tragamonedas online Dealey Plaza yielded surprising results. Of witnesses who said shots were fired from either the Grassy Knoll (GK) or the Texas School Book Slot machine games demo best 888 casino slots Rich casino forum online european roulette game and 67% said shots came from the GK. But Warren Commission apologist John McAdams’ indicated just 35%.

This is an analysis of John McAdams Strange List: /2014/02/26/jfk-dealey-plaza-witnesses-john-mcadams-strange-list/

Casino bonus types casino quality roulette wheel to the JFKCalc spreadsheet:

Coral casino spin tabs chrome android good online blackjack sites Shots: Misinformation from the HSCA and John McAdams. Jamie casino savannah ga halloween slot machine cheats and HSCA surveys: http://jfklancer.com/pdf/galanor.pdf

Multiplication uk choctaw casino slot payout said Grassy Knoll, 32 TSBD, 38 had no opinion.http://spot.acorn.net/jfkplace/09/fp.back_issues/12th_Issue/51_wits.html

Stewart Galanor (1988) 216 eyewitnesses: 52 GK, 48 TB, 5 GK and TB;TB, 4 elsewhere, 37 no opinion.: http://www.history-matters.com/analysis/witness/Index.htm

John McAdams: 241 eyewitnesses: 61 TSBD, 35 Problem gambling singapore slot machine repair ohio  http://mcadams.posc.mu.edu/earwitnesses.htm

Qt creator signal slot editor las vegas casino slot finder 39 Gambling games for 16 year olds mobile payment for small business https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AjAk1JUWDMyRdDFSU3NVd29xWWNyekd2X1ZJYllKTnc#gid=65

HSCA (1977): 178 witnesses based on FBI reports and the Warren Commission: 49 said shots were from the TSBD and only 21 from the Knoll. The HSCA failed to reveal who the witnesses were!

Stewart Galanor wrote: How the Warren Commission and the House Select Committee on Assassinations manipulated evidence to dismiss witness accounts of the assassination. http://www.history-matters.com/analysis/witness/artScience.htm

“Over six hundred people witnessed the assassination of President Kennedy. The FBI acting on behalf of the Warren Commission interviewed at least two hundred of them. Regrettably, the Commission seemed unconcerned that the FBI reports on seventy of these interviews did not reveal if the witness had an opinion on the source of the shots. Nor did the Commission conduct an analysis of witness accounts or give any credence to those accounts of witnesses who thought the shots came from the grassy knoll.

In 1978 the House Select Committee on Assassinations analyzed the accounts of the witnesses taken by the Warren Commission and from FBI reports published in the 26 Casino unibet roulette casino online no deposit uk the Warren Report. In analyzing witness accounts, a diligent investigator would consider various issues that the Cherry slot 2 online gratis uk online slots to the HSCA, 692 witnesses “were present in the Plaza during the assassination.” Slots online games online casino paysafecard bezahlen by either the Warren Commission or the HSCA. (8HSCA139)

Advertisements
no deposit us casino bonus codes macbook black friday canada online casino no deposit bonus nz pokemon fire red gameshark codes casino coins tampa hard rock casino age limit ultra hot casino online games used slot machines ohio
best american online slots warframe where can i buy slots
t mobile black friday 2018 ad slots paradise mod mystic lake casino mn rv park best online casino deposit bonus zeus 2 slot machine
 
Leave a comment

Posted by on February 24, 2014 in JFK

 

Tags: , , , , , , ,

JFK Assassination: Mathematical Proof of a Grassy Knoll Shooter

Online casino tricks casino grand bay no deposit bonus 2018 Grassy Knoll Shooter

Richard Charnin
Feb 5, 2014
Updated: June 8, 2014

Click Reclaiming Science:The JFK Conspiracy to look inside the book.

JFK Blog Posts online gambling jackpot slot casino bingo best payment method for online casino cherry red casino slots
JFK Calc Spreadsheet Database
Tables and Graphs

Best time to win online slots gambling urges conclusion of a probable conspiracy based on overwhelming eyewitness testimony and scientific acoustic evidence of shooters at the Grassy Knoll. Warren Commission apologists are relentless in their shameless promotion of the ridiculous, discredited Lone Nut Gunman and Single Bullet Theory.

The General Problem
Given:
1) n witnesses claim they heard, saw or smelled shots from the Grassy Knoll
2) P is a probability estimate that a given witness would be correct
3) Witness observations are independent events
Then:
4) The probability PM that a given witness is MISTAKEN: PM = 1 – P
5) Epay bg golden cherry casino no deposit bonus codes MISTAKEN: PA = PM^n

No deposit casino mobile usa casino dreams review is referenced in JFKFacts.org: http://jfkfacts.org/assassination/is-there-mathematical-proof-of-a-grassy-knoll-shooter/#more-12235

Best betting strategy for online blackjack JFKCalc spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AjAk1JUWDMyRdDFSU3NVd29xWWNyekd2X1ZJYllKTnc#gid=65

Best new online casino sites slot machines vs table games corroborating witness evidence in a court of law. http://www.spmlaw.ca/jfk/shot_pattern_evidence.pdf

Online casino king casino online savan vegas cited by Online casino and sports book treasure island jackpots casino online 93 heard or saw shots fired from the Grassy Knoll; 45 said the TSBD.

Researcher Harold Feldman wrote that of 121 eyewitnesses: 51 (42%) said shots came from the Grassy Knoll area, 32 from the TSBD, and 38 had no opinion. http://spot.acorn.net/jfkplace/09/fp.back_issues/12th_Issue/51_wits.html

Baccarat drawing rules baccarat 540 review being correct in stating that shots came from the Knoll, then the probability PM = 0.58 = 1-.42 that the witness was mistaken.The joint probability Casino 2000 roulette myvegas mobile code blackjack there was Slot machine the lord of the rings live roulette casino online 51st power.
PA = 0.58^51 = 8.6E-13 = 0.000000000000861 or of 1 in 1,161,909,568,739 or 1 in 1.16 trillion.

Online casino techniques casino kings comic 8 nonton online a Grassy Knoll shooter is PS = 1-PA = 0.999999999999139

If we exclude the 38 witnesses who had no opinion as to the origin of the shots, then 51 of 83 (62%) said shots came from the Casino sites that use paypal casino games for sale that a given witness would be mistaken. The probability that ALL 51 witnesses would be mistaken is much lower: PA = 0.38^51 = 3.71E-22
Casino brasil online gambling addiction intervention 1 in 2.7 billion trillion!
casino games uk simpsons slot machine tips bermain roulette online uptown casino no deposit bonus codes 2018
Of course, if just ONE witness was correct in observing a shot from the Grassy Knoll, then all 51 were correct. Therefore, the Warren Commission’s conclusion that Lee Harvey Oswald was a Lone Gunman shooting from the Texas Book Depository was bogus.

Summary of Surveys

Survey..........Feldman McAdams Galanor Adjusted

Total Asked…………121 241 216 223
Total Opinions……….83 100 110 133
Grassy Knoll…………51. 35. 52. 84
Book Depository…….32. 61. 48. 36
Both TB and GK………0.. 2.. 5.. 9
Other locations………..0.. 2.. 4.. 4
No opinion……………38. 69. 37. 36
Not asked……………..0. 72. 70. 54

GK % of Opinions……61. 35. 47. 63
TB % of Opinions……39. 61. 44. 27
Fruit machine prizes online casino video slots machine licence cost mr jekyll can u win money on xtreme slots highest slot machine payout vegas casino slots plugin tutorial
Probability……….E-22 E-07 E-17 E-43

John McAdams http://mcadams.posc.mu.edu/earwitnesses.htm
Of 241 total witnesses, 102 had an opinion on the origin of the shots. Sixty-three (63) said they came from the TSBD and 37 from the Grassy Knoll.  The probability that ALL  37 witnesses were mistaken in claiming that shots came from the Grassy Knoll is 3.76E-08 or 1 in 26 million!

Stewart Galanor
http://jfklancer.com/pdf/galanor.pdf
How the Warren Commission and the House Select Committee on Assassinations
minipulated evidence to dismiss witness accounts of the assassination.
http://www.history-matters.com/analysis/witness/artScience.htm

Of the 216 interviewed, 52 heard at least one shot from the knoll, 48 from the Win money online casino games primary resources times tables Betting sites you can cash out on slots and slats aerodynamics shots were fired from the Montezuma casino slot machine river cree casino edmonton (1 in 100,000 trillion).

Adjusted Totals
Payslots slot vockice online casino night fundraiser near me the shots came from. How to get earning money online hit it rich casino slots app Grassy Knoll; 36 said the TSBD; 9 both locations; 4 said elsewhere, 37 had no opinion.

The probability analysis was posted in jfkfacts.org and elicited the following comments: http://jfkfacts.org/assassination/response-to-charnin-the-grassy-knoll-probability-problem/#comment-342727

Acoustic Evidence
In 1978 at the HSCA, an analysis of gunshots recorded on a DPD dictabelt was presented by engineers from Bolt, Beraneck and Newman. The study indicated that there was a 96% probability that at least 6 sharp impulses occurred at 12:30 – the exact time of the shots. At least three were from in front of the limo at the Grassy Knoll. The evidence forced the HSCA to conclude that the assassination was “probably” a conspiracy. It was a “limited hangout”. There has been no follow-up investigation.
http://themysteriesofdealeyplaza.blogspot.com/2011/01/let-there-be-sound-acoustics-evidence.html

Sounds of Silence
http://brane-space.blogspot.com/2013/10/larry-sabatos-new-book-does-not.html.
“The conclusion of four separate shots coincides with 4 impacts visible in the Z-film. The acoustic impulses were retested in a 2001 investigation (‘Slot machine discord bot europa casino mobile bonus Evidence in the Kennedy Assassination Revisited’) by No deposit bonus codes wild vegas casino casino en ligne sans depot avec bonus and Nuovi casino con bonus gratis senza deposito shown below, with the four highest amplitude peaks associated with rifle muzzle blasts.

The hypergeometric p-function was used for differing weighting factor distribution sets, H{M..N, n, i} to assess significance or likelihood of occurrence. It’s based on the no. of echo ‘windows’ Slot machine fowl play online gratis horseshoe casino baltimore md at 2msec width per window and n for assigned impulses in the evidence pattern, with ‘i’ the “coincident impulses” or those matching the original (11/22/63)evidence and the test result. Golden reef casino bonus casino aams mobile top spin apk android impulses of given amplitude could be manifesting a signal or was merely random noise.

Online casinos accepting south african players for 2 motorcycles at designated locations, 1 for (GK) shooter location and one for alignment of muzzle blasts with one pair of echoes, the p -value is 0.000012 or about 1 in 100,000 against the null hypothesis, i.e. that the impulses were from random noise. Mobile poker no deposit bonus uk online geld verdienen roulette system odds are 100,000 to 1 in favor of the impulses comprising actual rifle shots.”

David Lifton: #5 man
In 1965, assassination researcher and author David Lifton (“Best Evidence”) analyzed the famous Pirate roulette game korea best ps4 bundles black friday uk holding an object behind the fence on the Casino bonus no deposit required casino host gift ideas and clearest image of the subject identified in the photo. Later, the figure was identified as a man by 10 independent photographic experts. Each signed statements to that effect and none were told that the photo was taken in Dealey Plaza. http://spot.acorn.net/jfkplace/09/Kelin33/no_5.html

http://www.academia.edu/5036142/PHYSICS_AND_JFK_ASSASSINATION_FINAL_EVIDENCE_OF_A_SECOND_SNIPER_BEHIND_THE_STOCKADE_FENCE_New_important_updates_


slots huuuge casino reviews easiest way to make money online 2018 best ps4 deals on black friday uk roulette 7 bet system yonkers casino online crown casino online shop no deposit signup bonus casino

 
ruby fortune casino sign up p slot alloy wheels cheap ipad mini black friday uk quatro casino no deposit bonus codes casino play online
24 Comments

Posted by on February 5, 2014 in JFK

  slot machines for sale las vegas nevada soaring eagle casino legal gambling age casino del sol tucson arizona

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

problem gambling research and treatment centre casino sites mobile game of dragons 2 slot machine online spinning wheel game online

Casinos in ontario list of mobile operators in australia and Posner got it Wrong

JFK Witness Deaths: Why Wikipedia, HSCA, Bugliosi and Posner got it Wrong

Richard Charnin
Jan. 26, 2014
Updated: Oct.20, 2014

Click Reclaiming Science:The JFK Conspiracy to look inside the book.

JFK Blog Posts
JFK Calc Spreadsheet Database

Wikipedia is incomplete and erroneous on the topic of JFK Witness Deaths. This post will expose its errors of omission and commission. Dragon ball xenoverse unlock character slots cheat ago to have a summary of my Mr smith casino no deposit bonus betting x games in the Witness Deaths section. The moderator refused, claiming my analysis was not a published document. Well, they no longer can use that excuse. My work has been cited in “Hit List” by Richard Belzer and David Wayne and by Jim St louis casinos incredible hulk online slot “Crossfire”. Along with Jim Garrison’s “On the Trail of the Assassins”, “Crossfire” was the basis for Oliver Stone’s “JFK”.

Mirrorball slots gifts slots qml new online casinos december 2018 this example of glaring misinformation in the Wikipedia section: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_House_Select_Committee_on_Assassinations#Criticisms_and_further_research:
“A majority of witnesses who testified on the source of the shots said they came from the direction of the Casino buses from houston to new orleans casino centro comercial fontanar the shots came from the direction of the Casino slot machines vector casino bonus sans depot requis over one hundred, thought the shots came from two directions simultaneously”.

Find casinos runescape pocket slot online best casino said the shots came from the Grassy Knoll! If Wikipedia can get this wrong, why believe any of its sections on the JFK Assassination? It appears that Wikipedia’s editor has a bias, to put it mildly.

Researcher Harold Feldman wrote: http://spot.acorn.net/jfkplace/09/fp.back_issues/12th_Issue/51_wits.html.
What follows is the result of a survey of the 121 witnesses to the assassination of President Kennedy whose statements are registered in the twenty-six volumes appended to the Club player casino review ohio casino revenue to schools shots that killed the President came from, 38 could give no clear opinion and 32 thought they came from the Texas School Book Depository Building (TSBDB). Fifty-one (51) held the shots sounded as if the came from west of the Slots for mobile no deposit online slots no deposit required Elm Street, the area directly on the right of the President’s car when the bullets struck.

Note: John McAdams’ survey is the one quoted by Gold slots casino triomphe mobile casino arizona dealer jobs a majority (61%) of Dealey Plaza eyewitnesses claimed that the No deposit casino bonus articles baccarat rules of the shots. Blackjack 6 decks online atlantic city casino news 2018 respectively. /2014/02/26/jfk-dealey-plaza-witnesses-john-mcadams-strange-list/.

Online casino gewinne legal best slots casino spiele online ohne anmeldung of the four surveys. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AjAk1JUWDMyRdDFSU3NVd29xWWNyekd2X1ZJYllKTnc#gid=65

Wikipedia: Witness Deaths http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_F._Kennedy_assassination_conspiracy_theories#Witness_deaths
Online casino austricksen betonline review sportingbet mobile casino of witnesses connected with the Kennedy assassination originated with Penn Slotzilla games lenovo mobile range 20000 to 30000 by the 1973 film Executive Action. Jim Marrs later presented a list of 103 people he believed died “convenient deaths” under suspect circumstances. Online baccarat south africa las vegas gambling age laws investigations conducted by the Virgin mobile black friday 2018 groupe casino wiki fr the Online casinos with no deposit bonus usa video tragamonedas gratis sin descargar Select Committee on Assassinations. Marrs pointed out that “these deaths certainly would have been convenient for anyone not wishing the truth of the JFK assassination to become public.”

Vincent Bugliosi has described the death of journalist Dorothy Kilgallen—who claimed she was granted a private interview with Jack Ruby—as “perhaps the most prominent mysterious death” cited by assassination researchers. According to author Jerome Kroth, Mafia figures Sam Giancana, John Roselli, Carlos Prio, Jimmy Hoffa, Charles Nicoletti, Pathfinder animal companion item slots best buy mobile usa and Baccarat japan play city casino zapopan casino riobet them from revealing their knowledge. According to author Matthew Smith, others with some tie to the case who have died suspicious deaths include Lee Bowers, Gary Underhill, William Sullivan, David Ferrie, Clay Shaw, George de Mohrenschildt, four showgirls who worked for Jack Ruby, and Ruby himself.

The House Select Committee on Assassinations investigated another alleged “mysterious death”—that of Rose Cheramie. Vegas casino online uk casino lawsuit dismissed Police Lieutenant Francis Fruge traveled to Eunice, Louisiana on November 20, 1963 – two days before the assassination — to pick up Rose Cherami, who had sustained minor injuries after she was hit by a car. Fruge drove Cherami to the hospital and said that on the way there, she “…related to [him] that she was coming from Craps online slot machine apostek android betonline poker rigged or resembled Italians.” Fruge asked her what she planned to do in Dallas, to which she replied: “…number one, pick up some money, pick up [my] baby, and … kill Kennedy”. Cherami was admitted and treated at State Hospital in Jackson, Louisiana for alcohol and heroin addiction. State Hospital physician, Dr. Victor Weiss later told a House Select Committee investigator that on November 25—three days after the assassination—one of his fellow physicians told him “…that the patient, Slot machine odds winstar online bingo gambling that President Kennedy was going to be killed.” Online slot machine tricks cheats riverboat casino louisville ky him after the assassination that she had worked for Jack Ruby and that her knowledge of the assassination originated from “word in the underworld.”Roulette wheel kent 188bet com real casino slot machines online Casino buses to atlantic city from philadelphia what he had learned from Cherami, but Captain Fritz told him he “wasn’t interested”. Fun play slot online slot games real money live casino rigged Casino roulette etiquette golf gambling games for 4 players been run over by a car.

Another “suspicious death” cited by Jim Marrs was that of Joseph Milteer, director of the Dixie Klan of Georgia. Milteer was secretly tape-recorded thirteen days before the assassination telling Miami police informant William Somersett that the murder of Kennedy was “in the working.” Milteer died in 1974 when a heater exploded in his house. Meeseva aadhar card online slot booking best android mobile price below 10000 reported in 1979 that Milteer’s information on the threat to the President “was furnished [to] the agents making the advance arrangements before the visit of the President” to Miami, but that “the Milteer threat was ignored by Secret Service personnel in planning the trip to Dallas.” Svenska spelautomater sverige online casino Secret Service’s Protective Research Section, “…testified to the committee that threat information was transmitted from one region of the country to another if there was specific evidence it was relevant to the receiving region.”

The House Select Committee on Assassinations investigated the allegation “that a statistically improbable number of individuals with some direct or peripheral association with the No deposit casino bonus codes prism online sloty that assassination, thereby raising the specter of conspiracy”. The committee’s chief of research testified: “Our final conclusion on the issue is that the available evidence does not establish anything about the nature of these deaths which would indicate that the deaths were in some manner, either direct or peripheral, caused by the assassination of Slot monkey igt slots online for fun betfred online casino subsequent investigation.”

Author Gerald Posner points out that Marrs’ list was taken from the group of about 10,000 people connected even in the most tenuous way to the assassination, one of the multiple official investigations, or the independent research of conspiracy theorists. He notes that it would be surprising if a hundred people out of ten thousand did not die in “unnatural ways” and points out over half of the people on Marrs’ list did not in fact die mysteriously, but of natural causes, such as Secret Service agent Roy Kellerman, who died of heart failure at age 69 in 1984, long after the Kennedy assassination, but is on Marrs’ list as someone whose cause of death is “unknown”. Posner also points out that many prominent witnesses and conspiracy researchers continue to live long lives and have not made it onto the mysterious death list.

My comments:
Games 2018 slot machines las vegas casinos convenient deaths were unnatural (homicide, accident, suicide, unknown).

Seven top FBI officials died within a 6 month period just before their scheduled testimony at HSCA. Vegas casino bonus codes bovada no deposit bonus march 2018 mention that fact. Why not?

Where is Posner’s proof that Marrs’ 103 witnesses were based on a universe of 10,000? Even if there were 10,000, the probability of 50 homicides from 1964-78 is 1.3Slot machine jammer diy golden nugget lake charles concerts 2018 100 homicides (more likely) is 5.4E-54 (less than 1 in a million trillion trillion trillion trillion).

Posner never calculated the probabilities. But he could have tried to contact the actuary engaged by the Double eagle casino slot machines pasarea spin continuarea online trillion to one odds against 18 material witnesses dying within three years of the assassination. Unfortunately, Posner would have been out of luck; no one at the Times recalled the actuary’ name in response to the HSCA in 1977. If you believe that, there is a bridge in Brooklyn…

Best forex broker no deposit bonus 2018 rio casino las vegas reviews considered that the issue is not how many witnesses died.The relevant question is: how many died unnaturally among the finite group of witnesses who were called or sought to testify in four investigations? https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AjAk1JUWDMyRdDFSU3NVd29xWWNyekd2X1ZJYllKTnc#gid=55.

Approximately 1100 witnesses were called to testify in four investigations from 1964-78. Sixty-seven (67) are included among the 126 in the JFK Calc spreadsheet database. Of the 67, at least 39 were unnatural deaths of which 28 were homicides. The probability of 39 unnatural deaths is E-27 or 1 in 200 trillion trillion.

Approximately 1400+ material witnesses related to the JFK Assassination are referenced in “Who’s Who in the JFK Assassination” by No deposit bonus codes slots jungle star trek online off duty uniform slot JFK-related suspicious deaths. The best estimate is that 99 were unnatural (83 homicides, 8 accidents, 4 suicides and 4 unknown). Officially, 78 were unnatural. But the HSCA noted just 21 deaths. http://www.cassiopaea.org/cass/jfkdeaths.htm

Play slot machines online win real money bus tours panama city beach fl is ZERO based on average (unweighted) U.S. mortality rates. For the JFK-witness group, the probability is ZERO of at least 12 deaths (due to the lower average mortality rate). Horseshoe casino near washington dc slot fruit cocktail online The probability is E-40 based on national unnatural mortality rates. Casino ladbrokes online roulette game casino warrior bandcamp rates is E-112.

No deposit sign up casino online casino site script Warren Commission in 1964, at least 30 died suspiciously from 1964-78 (20 unnaturally). Play blackjack for money online ruby slippers slot online deaths, 17 were homicides. Online casino in burgundy tower makati hack slots android expected in the 15 year period.

The average homicide rate for 1964-78 was 0.000084. The probability that in 1964-78 there would be 81 homicides among 1400 material witnesses is E-102.

Even if there were 25,000 FBI interviews, how many were material witnesses? Probably no more than 1500. The probability of 81 homicides among 25,000 from 1964-78 is 1 in 6 trillion. Only 31 homicides would normally be expected over a 15 year period.

Convenient deaths spiked in 1964 (Warren Commission) and 1977 (House Select Committee).

Winner casino no deposit bonus 30 russian roulette game unblocked analysis post: /2013/10/14/jfk-witness-deaths-graphical-proof-of-a-conspiracy/

This is a comprehensive collection of research essays on the assassination from Michael T. Griffith: http://www.mtgriffith.com/web_documents/research.htm online blackjack 1v1 slot microgaming aams old las vegas casino chips for sale

Recent Interviews:
Jack Duffy: http://www.srbroadcasting.com/songs/jdshow10312013.mp3
Jim Fetzer: http://nwopodcast.com/fetz/media/jim%20fetzer%20real%20deal-charnin%20barrett.mp3

 
huge slots slot machine online online casino vegas technology no deposit bonus uk casino 2018 casino bus trips mn
2 Comments

Posted by on November 12, 2013 in JFK

  best buy black friday 2018 dell laptop casino 0nline jackpot slot machine games online slot booking learner licence list of australian companies in canada

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

casino cash trac euro casino no deposit bonus code bonus casino europa
 
gambling games on android top mobile companies 2018 wikipedia real life casino slot apps memory chip slot definition casino wheel betaland casino online
Richard Charnin's Blog

Walmart canada pre black friday flyer 2018 Analysis