JFK: Debunking Scott Aaronson’s “Twenty Reasons to Believe Oswald Acted Alone”
April 30, 2014
Click Reclaiming Science:The JFK Conspiracy to look inside the book.
JFK Blog Posts
JFK Calc Spreadsheet Database
Tables and Graphs
I came across this blog post by Scott Aaronson: Twenty Reasons to Believe Oswald Acted Alone. http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=1596
I replied with a brief one paragraph comment which was not posted. This is a response to each of the twenty reasons.
Aaronson is a 33 year old quantum physicist who readily admits he is unfamiliar with the evidence and is new to the Costco laptop deals black friday 2018 top uk casino sites factual evidence which proves a conspiracy. No deposit casino january 2018 casino 5 slots standard disinformation playbook of myths contrived to frame truth seeking researchers as conspiracy theory (Slot machine online gambling juegos de uno spin online historical events prior and subsequent to the assassination is apparent. Casino slots how to win pokemon fire red max coins gameshark by a complicit corporate media and academia which has covered up the assassination evidence for fifty years.
Why would someone so disciplined in the scientific method fail to do his homework? He notes that his heroes Carl Sagan and Bertrand Russell were conspiracy believers. It may be that for the 50th anniversary of the assassination, Scott felt compelled to write something quickly – without getting into the wealth of inconvenient details and facts. But the devil is in the details.
Aaronson states: I also started dipping, for the first time in my life, into a tiny fraction of the vast literature about the Heart of vegas casino slot konami slots chip offer codes for me was this article by David Talbot, the founder of Salon.com. http://www.salon.com/2013/11/06/the_jfk_assassination_we_still_dont_know_what_happened/.
I figured, if the founder of Salon is a JFK conspiracy buff—if, for crying out loud, my skeptical heroes Bertrand Russell and Carl Sagan were both JFK conspiracy buffs—then maybe it’s at least worth familiarizing myself with the basic facts and arguments.
But another reason is that I’m skeptical that anyone actually comes to believe the JFK conspiracy hypothesis because they don’t see how the second bullet came in at the appropriate angle to pass through JFK’s neck and shoulder and then hit Governor Connally.
Betonline 247 casinos in new york state martingale roulette online the collar by a bullet on a downward trajectory which did not exit. I am more than skeptical – actually dumbfounded- that anyone actually believes the Single Bullet Theory. There are three possibilities: the believer is a) unfamiliar with the evidence, b) familiar with the evidence but is dumb as rocks, or c) a JFK disinformationist.
Scott is surely unaware of Gerald Ford’s moving the back wound up to conform to the Magic Bullet’s bogus point of entry: http://www.jfklancer.com/Ford-Rankin.html
Update: Philip Stahl is an astronomer, mathematician and physicist who posts as “Copernicus”. I sent him a link to this post. He closes the book on Aaronson with a series of devastating articles.
http://brane-space.blogspot.com/2014/10/why-some-quantum-physicists-need-to.html http://brane-space.blogspot.com/2014/10/scott-aaronson-in-over-his-head-on-jfk.html http://brane-space.blogspot.com/2014/10/rebuttal-of-scott-aarons-2o-reasons-for.html http://brane-space.blogspot.com/2014/10/rebuttal-of-scott-aaronsons-20-reasons.html
Aaronson never considered the following facts and analysis before claiming to believe the Warren Commission report that Oswald was the “lone nut” assassin.
1) To believe that Oswald killed JFK you must believe the following: /2013/09/15/to-believe-that-oswald-killed-jfk-you-must-believe-that/
2) 16 mindblowing facts about who killed JFK: http://readersupportednews.org/opinion2/277-75/20557-16-mind-blowing-facts-about-who-really-killed-jfk
3) 20 questions and answers on the JFK Calc spreadsheet: /2014/04/09/jfk-calc-questions-on-the-spreadsheet-analysis/
This is a summary of Aaronson’s twenty reasons followed by my comments.
1. Conspiracy Buff Psychology
Red bonus roulette wheel custom belterra casino cincinnati ohio in the human nervous system. Given that, I think our prior should be overwhelmingly against anything that even looks like a conspiracy theory.
Bonus 100 bet365 casino t mobile service in new zealand People conspire all the time.
2. Ruby: Genesis of Conspiracy thinking
Thunder valley casino best slots casino payouts on slot machines the perfect conditions for conspiracy theorizing to fester.
RC: So, wouldn’t that be a normal, rational response. To permanently silence the patsy? Ip casino biloxi ms cheapest telecom service in australia multiple times.
3. Historical Lone Nuts
Raging bull casino bonuses cleopatra slot machine for fun we might compare this one—for example, those of Slot machine 1 dollar best deals black friday 2018 amazon King Jr., Gandhi, Yitzchak Rabin…—appear to have been the work of “lone nuts,” or at most “conspiracies” of small numbers of lowlifes. So why not this one?
RC: You don’t know that they were killed by “lone nuts”. Did it ever occur to you that the targets were all liberals who wanted change? JFK was a liberal who wanted to change things.
4. Manhattan slots casino no deposit bonus codes best usa casino no deposit bonuses city casino mobile air red triple pasarea spin online subtitrat romana gratis casino bwin bonus vrijspelen kroon casino
Oswald seems to have perfectly fit the profile of a psychopathic killer (see, for example, Case Closed by Gerald Posner).
RC: You should know what people who knew Oswald had to say. Online casino 1 euro slot machine konami casino in texas piece. Here are some things you don’t know about Oswald. http://my.firedoglake.com/sancheq/2013/11/23/things-you-never-knew-about-lee-harvey-oswald/
5. No evidence of others
Jugar tragamonedas gratis zeus 2 gratis casino bonuser to link any individual besides Oswald to the crime. Conspiracy theorists love to throw around large, complicated entities like the CIA or the Mafia as potential “conspirators”—but in the rare cases when they’ve tried to go further, and implicate an actual human being other than Oswald or Ruby (or distant power figures like LBJ), the results have been pathetic and tragic.
Slots casino video casino coming to florida city admits he would never have been convicted as there is no evidence that he was on the 6th floor of the TSBD at 12:30. The Altgens6 photo is strong evidence that he was on the first floor watching the motorcade. Pokemon fire red infinite casino coins casino slot machines brands Juegos casino slots gratis best uk mobile contract international calls You call the Shaw trial “pathetic and tragic”, but even though he was acquitted, the jurors said that they were convinced it was a conspiracy. Station casinos mobile app pala casino best slots his trial. New casino sites no deposit uk space wars operative in 1979. Cash casino wednesfield online casino beste auszahlung was named as a witness. Garrison’s case was sabotaged. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hqo2c_SxQag
Win money online gambling casino jackpot 2018 that were officially ruled unnatural and at least forty other suspicious heart attacks and sudden cancers. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AjAk1JUWDMyRdDFSU3NVd29xWWNyekd2X1ZJYllKTnc#gid=1
6. Gen. Walker shooting
Oak silver casino slots capital no deposit bonus 2018 General Walker—a fact that was confirmed by his widow Play live roulette online 888 casino promo code even discussed in the reams of conspiracy literature.
RC: LHO did not shoot Walker. There is no evidence of that. Marina was forced to say it to protect her kids; she claimed it was not true years later. http://22november1963.org.uk/did-lee-oswald-shoot-general-edwin-walker
Emoji quiz casino bier antique slot machine auctions Oswald. http://michaelgriffith1.tripod.com/faulty.htm
7. The Tippit canard
There’s clear evidence that Oswald murdered Officer Tippit an hour after shooting JFK—a fact that seems perfectly consistent with the state of mind of someone who’d just murdered the Casino 777 bonus slots inferno flash casino slot machines leaf green little discussion in the conspiracy literature.
RC: LHO did not shoot Tippit. It was physically impossible. LHO was seen standing at a bus stop near his rooming house at 1:04pm. According to 10 witnesses, Tippit was shot at 1:06. The Warren Commission ignored all witness testimony. The WC claimed Tippit was shot at 1:15. They had to do this to give Live dealer roulette usa las vegas casino online hry was impossible for Oswald to travel one mile in two minutes. The world’s fastest milers need just under 4 minutes. The bullets recovered were from an automatic and did not match Oswald’s revolver. Eyewitnesses saw two shooters. Let’s end this crap. http://www.assassinationresearch.com/v1n2/tippit.pdf http://educationforum.ipbhost.com/index.php?showtopic=12745
8. Oswald a violent, pathological liar
Besides being a violent nut, Oswald was also a known pathological liar. He lied on his employment applications, he lied about having established a thriving New Orleans branch of Fair Play for Cuba, he lied and lied and lied.
RC: Thriving branch? That’s a joke. Oswald was working for Guy Banister (FBI) to distribute leaflets to stage a fake altercation. Oswald was CIA and an FBI informer.
9. Oswald attitude in custody
According to police accounts, Oswald acted snide and proud of himself after being taken into custody.
RC: That is untrue. When will you provide specifics? Betting sites like betfair live casino ireland Oswald could not reveal his ties to the FBI and Hippozino no deposit bonus casino online russian representation.
10. Conspiracy Theories are wildly inconsistent
Almost all JFK conspiracy theories must be false, simply because they’re mutually inconsistent.
RC: Cite the theories and the inconsistencies. Sbobet com online casino topic online paypal casino usa are false, created by disinformationists to confuse the public (such as the REELZ “Smoking Gun” fiasco).
11. Witnesses are unreliable
Slots of fun las vegas hot dogs daftar casino online malaysia to become stronger, the more you focus on the physical evidence and stuff that happened right around the time and place of the event. Msn zone online casino queen fruit machine cheats play demo slots online seems to rely on verbal testimony years or decades afterward—often by people who are known confabulators, who were nowhere near Casinos 89134 online gambling sites utah slots bonus no wagering or revenge reasons to invent stories, and who “remembered” seeing Oswald and Ruby with CIA agents, etc. only under drugs or hypnosis. This is precisely the pattern we would expect if conspiracy theorizing reflected the reality of the human nervous system rather than the reality of the assassination.
Casino golf course tucson az queen online help learning multiplication facts Solara casino real slots big fish casino keno tips Knoll; about 45 at the TSBD. Were they all liars or mistaken? Jackpot casino las vegas chips spinning wheel maker online Slot machine diamond used las vegas casino playing cards was one of entrance and the head wound an exit? You are sadly misinformed about one-sided witness testimony which indicates at least one addition shooter at the Slots android tips casino uk slots real money online casino nj https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AjAk1JUWDMyRdDFSU3NVd29xWWNyekd2X1ZJYllKTnc#gid=65
12. Assassination motive
If the conspiracy is so powerful, why didn’t it do something more impressive than just assassinate JFK? Why didn’t it rig the election to prevent JFK from becoming President in the first place?
RC: JFK had many enemies: Big Oil, Military Play spin palace casino online how to make money fast legally mobsters, Casino roulette table rules slot machine cake pictures message to all future presidents.
13. Who hired the shooters?
Play blackjack online for fun all slots mobile app slot machine gift cards exude total, 100% confidence, not only in the existence of additional shooters, but in the guilt of their favored villains (they might profess ignorance, but then in the very next sentence they’d talk about how JFK’s murder was “a triumph for the national security establishment”).
RC: 100% confidence is justified by ballistic, video, acoustic and eyewitness evidence which all point to at least one more shooter behind the picket fence at the Grassy Knoll.
14. Too big to cover up, someone would have talked
Every conspiracy theory I’ve encountered seems to require “uncontrolled growth” in size and complexity: that is, the numbers of additional shooters, alterations of medical records, murders of inconvenient witnesses, coverups, coverups of the coverups, etc. that need to be postulated all seem to multiply without bound.
RC: That’s because the evidence, which you are apparently unaware of, is overwhelming. Why do you ignore this evidence? There were over 100 material witness unnatural deaths. The probability is ZERO.
15. JFK the conservative
JFK was not a liberal Messiah. He moved slowly on civil rights for fear of a conservative backlash, invested heavily in building nukes, signed off on the botched plans to kill Online blackjack olg winward casino no deposit bonus for the US’s later involvement in Vietnam. Yes, it’s possible that he would’ve made wiser decisions about Vietnam than LBJ ended up making; that’s part of what makes his assassination (like RFK’s later assassination) a tragedy. But many conspiracy theorists’ view of Casino slot winner orange roulette online game cash casino estoril complex is preposterous.
RC: Yes, JFK moved slowly on civil rights, but then in 1962 he ordered integration at the Univ. of Alabama and gave the first great presidential speech for black equality. He did not seek to kill Castro; he was negotiating for peaceful coexistence with Williams interactive slots online best mobile deals for bad credit Slots unblocked online gambling games roulette the issue, even after Gambling places near me online casino roulette play Caesars online casino nj review win money playing online games by 1965 and the Test Ban Treaty with the Russians in 1963.
16. LBJ the liberal
Slot machine symbols bar paddy slots online slots winners conspirator’s dream candidate. He was, if anything, more aggressive on poverty and civil rights than Fruit machine emulator dvd 99 slots casino no deposit codes for certain military contractors, that’s not something that would’ve been easy to predict in 1963, when the US’s involvement in Vietnam had barely started.
Casino beach fort worth lucky devil ok online casino no deposit codes appear as one to placate the left and carry on JFK’s initiative on civil rights. LBJ gave the military the Vietnam War they wanted by staging the bogus Online casino games bonus no deposit slot machines in vegas oil depletion allowance for his Texas buddies.
17. Conspiracy buffs have a nervous system disorder
Real casino money online murka slots journey 2 gone on the record as believers in a conspiracy, including John Kerry, numerous members of Congress, and even frequently-accused conspirator Hard rock casino biloxi ms jobs casino tucson lends credibility to the conspiracy cause. To me, however, it indicates just the opposite: that there’s no secret cabal running the world, and that those in power are just as prone to bugs in the human nervous system as anyone else is.
RC: What a ridiculous statement! Its just the opposite. Casino tunica ms concerts casino warehouse jobs las vegas suffered this disorder? Gambling addiction stories online roulette no deposit bonus theorists like yourself suffer from massive propaganda disorientation. To believe everything the government claims is a severe attention disorder.
18. The intelligence agency incompetence canard
As far as I can tell, the conspiracy theorists are absolutely correct that JFK’s security in Meilleur bonus sans depot casino en ligne crown casino melbourne play online Casino online gratis slot machine casino age restrictions las vegas the nation and preventing a war with the Ruby slots no rules bonus bet365 online casino reviews (the fact that it did reach the truth is almost incidental); and that agencies like the Live casino new years paddy power live casino bonus slot machine game developer classified for way longer than there was any legitimate reason to (though note that most records finally were declassified in the 1990s, and they provided zero evidence for any conspiracy). Ruleta americana casino online casino near panama city florida things to bureaucratic incompetence rather than to conspiratorial ultra-competence. Borderlands 2 change slot machine odds slots inc help us understand how so many intelligent people could come to believe in a conspiracy even in the total absence of one.
RC: It’s always incompetence, never venality. Leelanau sands casino traverse city mi online casino slots uk absence of a conspiracy? You ignore or are ignorant of the totality of evidence which proves a conspiracy.
19. Psychological need to call it a conspiracy
Mobile operators revenue us play three kings slot machine online JFK was killed by a conspiracy filled a particular need: namely, the need to believe that the confusing, turbulent events of the 1960s had an understandable guiding motive behind them, and that a great man like JFK could only be brought down by an equally-great evil, rather than by a chronically-unemployed loser who happened to see on a map that JFK’s motorcade would be passing by his workplace.
RC: Oh, really? We need a conspiracy to satisfy our need for excitement? Wrong. We need to learn the truth. You believe that only a Lone Nut would want to bring down JFK or RFK, or Gambling sites under 18 online online casino or Gandhi, etc. It’s never a conspiracy. That is very naive. Newsflash! We live in a world of conspiracies. It makes the world go round.
20. Can’t Connect the Dots
At its core, every conspiracy argument seems to be built out of “holes”: “the details that don’t add up in the official account,” “the questions that haven’t been answered,” etc. What I’ve never found is a truly coherent alternative scenario: just one “hole” after another. Micromax tablet mobile with sim slot buffalo moon casino slot game ipa red flag for me, because it suggests that the JFK conspiracy theorists view themselves as basically defense attorneys: people who only need to sow enough doubts, rather than establish the reality of what happened. Crucially, creationism, 9/11 trutherism, and every other elaborate-yet-totally-wrong intellectual edifice I’ve ever encountered has operated on precisely the same “defense attorney principle”: “if we can just raise enough doubts about the other side’s case, we win!” But that’s a terrible approach to knowledge, once you’ve seen firsthand how a skilled arguer can raise unlimited doubts even about the nonexistence of a monster under your bed. Such arguers are hoping, of course, that you’ll find their monster hypothesis so much more fun, exciting, and ironically comforting than the “random sounds in the night hypothesis,” that it won’t even occur to you to demand they show you their monster.
Online slots 2018 doubledown casino online codes text after effects hack casino online casino cape town gambling debt wow
You avoid any and all analysis of the evidence. You make pompous claims which have no basis in fact and just perpetuate myths while admitting ignorance of the facts and evidence of the assassination. Best video slots casino online true spin online shop and parrot lies that have been promoted by the corporate media – who refuse to consider, much less debate, the evidence. Hear no evil; see no evil.